Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

Winner
The Thule Motion 3 XXL rooftop cargo box is a spacious and well-designed carrier ideal for families or anyone needing extra storage space on top of their vehicle. It offers a generous 21 cubic feet capacity and can hold up to 165 pounds, which suits most gear from luggage to sports equipment. Measuring about 96 by 39 by 20 inches, it’s quite large, so make sure your vehicle can accommodate its size. The box is made from durable aluminum, providing a strong and lightweight shell that helps protect your items. Its aerodynamic, wing-shaped design with a forward-leaning nose reduces wind drag, which can help improve fuel efficiency compared to bulkier carriers.
Mounting is straightforward thanks to the PowerClick quick-mount system, which signals when it’s securely attached, making installation faster and tool-free. Opening and closing the lid is easy with one hand, aided by a sturdy lid and wide handle, which adds convenience when loading or unloading. The SlideLock system enhances security by automatically locking the lid and showing when it’s properly closed, giving peace of mind that your belongings are safe. However, the box isn’t water resistant, so it’s best used in dry conditions or with waterproof bags inside. At 35 kilograms (about 77 pounds), it’s relatively heavy for installation, so some users may need assistance mounting it.
The box comes in a neutral titan color and offers optional accessories like interior lighting and protective liners, which are sold separately. This rooftop box represents a strong choice for anyone wanting a large, secure, and aerodynamic cargo carrier, especially if easy mounting and reliable locking are priorities.
The Yakima SkyBox NX XXL is a hard shell rooftop cargo carrier designed for ample storage, making it great for families or groups needing to transport bulky gear like camping equipment or skis up to 215 cm long. With 22 cubic feet of space, it offers generous capacity. The dual-sided access is a handy feature, allowing you to load and unload from both sides of your vehicle, which can save time and effort. Security is well covered with integrated SKS locks and a push-button system to keep your belongings safe during travel.
The box’s build feels durable and sleek, thanks to its flattened floor and smooth nano-texture finish, which also helps maintain a clean look. However, this model is not water resistant, so it may not protect your cargo fully in heavy rain or wet conditions. The mounting system is a universal roof mount, making it compatible with most vehicles, which adds flexibility. While aerodynamics are improved by its streamlined shape, the carrier still adds some wind resistance, potentially affecting fuel economy slightly.
This carrier is well suited for travelers who need a large, secure, and easy-to-use storage box on their roof, especially for dry weather trips. If rain protection is a priority, exploring other options may be advisable.
The SportRack Vista XL Rear Opening Cargo Box offers an impressive 18 cubic foot (510 L) internal cargo capacity, making it suitable for families or individuals who need extra storage space for road trips or outdoor adventures. Measuring 63 x 38 x 19 inches, it provides ample space without being excessively bulky. The cargo box is made from durable UV-resistant ABS material, ensuring it can withstand various weather conditions while maintaining its structural integrity over time. Its maximum weight capacity is 100 pounds (45 kg), which is adequate for most travel needs but may be limiting for heavier gear.
The rear-opening design enhances safety by allowing easy access from the back, away from traffic. Installation is straightforward with the tool-free mounting hardware, compatible with SportRack Rack Systems, square bars, round bars, and most factory racks, making it versatile for different vehicle types. Security is well-covered with an included key and lock system to protect your belongings. However, its aerodynamics might not be as advanced as some sleek, high-end models, potentially affecting fuel efficiency slightly.
Weighing 28 pounds, it is relatively lightweight, allowing for easier handling during installation and removal. The cargo box enjoys positive customer feedback, with a 4.4 out of 5-star rating from over 2,200 reviews, indicating general satisfaction with its performance. While it ranks high in the vehicle hard-shell carriers category, its bulkiness might not appeal to users with smaller cars or those looking for ultra-lightweight options. Nonetheless, it stands out as a solid choice for those who prioritize capacity, durability, and ease of access.