10 Best Wood Filler For Screw Holes 2026 in the United States

The Gorilla All Purpose Wood Filler is a strong choice for filling screw holes and other wood repairs, especially if you need a water-resistant option for both indoor and outdoor use. Its acrylic-based formula spreads easily for a smooth, natural finish that can be sanded, painted, or stained, allowing you to customize the look to match your woodwork. The filler is designed not to shrink or crack, which helps maintain durability over time.

This makes it dependable for fixing cracks, gouges, and holes, while also reinforcing nails and screws—a handy feature if you want added strength in repairs. If you want a versatile, tough wood filler that balances ease of use with reliable durability and finish customization, this one fits well. It might be less ideal if you need pre-colored fillers that match wood tones right out of the tub.

J-B Weld 8267 SteelStik is a two-part epoxy putty designed primarily for metal and other hard surfaces rather than wood. It sets quickly—within 5 minutes—and fully cures in about an hour, which is a big plus if you need a fast repair. You can shape, sand, drill, and tap it after curing, offering good flexibility for filling holes.

Because it's steel-reinforced and dark grey in color, it doesn’t blend well with wood, making color matching a challenge if you want a natural wood look. This putty is highly durable, resistant to heat (up to 350°F continuous), chemicals, and moisture, meaning repairs will last a long time and resist wear. However, it’s not specifically formulated to absorb stain or paint like traditional wood fillers, limiting options if you want to finish or refinish the wood surface smoothly.

For screw holes in wood, it might be overkill and less cosmetically suitable compared to wood-based fillers that dry clear or can be stained. When you need a tough, fast, and water-resistant filler for mixed materials or wood in harsh conditions, SteelStik performs well.

The Gorilla All Purpose Wood Filler in walnut color is a strong choice for filling screw holes and other wood repairs, both indoors and outdoors. Its acrylic formula is water resistant, which helps it stand up well to moisture without shrinking or cracking—making it durable for many types of projects. You can sand it down smoothly after it dries, allowing for a natural finish that blends well with surrounding wood.

Additionally, it’s stainable and paintable, so you can customize the color to match your wood surfaces more closely. This filler also works beyond just filling holes—it can anchor nails and screws, which is a useful bonus for carpentry tasks. The walnut color pairs well with darker wood tones, although achieving a perfect color match might require some additional staining or painting depending on your wood type.

This Gorilla product provides a reliable and versatile option that combines strength with ease of use and a nice finish, making it suitable for most DIY wood repairs.